A part of Watch Media

ShippingWatchSaturday28 January 2023

  • Search
  • Log in
  • Carriers
  • Logistics
  • Regulation
  • Suppliers
  • Search
  • Log in
  • Latest
  • Search
  • Log in
  • Carriers
  • Logistics
  • Regulation
  • Suppliers
  • Offshore
  • Ports
29/12/2015at 09:58

OW Bunker execs under attack in comprehensive review

Shareholders lacked access to vital information in the IPO prospectus for OW Bunker. Key persons, banks and equity fund Altor are under attack in a 400-page review by ad hoc trustee.
Photo: OW Bunker
BY JAKOB SKOUBOE, FINANSWATCH

The prospectus for the OW Bunker IPO contains "significant misinformation."

This is the conclusion from ad hoc trustee Søren Halling-Overgaard in a 400-page review, which FinansWatch and ShippingWatch are in possession of.

Thus a new page has been turned in the dispute regarding bankrupt company OW Bunker, which failed after barely eight months on the stock exchange, November 7th of last year. The review has been highly anticipated - and feared - by pivotal figures in the OW Bunker executive management, because it points the finger at the people, who according to the trustees, are responsible for the company's collapse. And the review raises significant criticism of the prospectus - which is the sales pitch of 271 pages, constituting the foundation of the Initial Public Offering of OW Bunker.

Here is the report on liability in the collapse of OW Bunker 

The prospectus is shot down. It contains "excluded", "incorrect" and/or "misleading" and/or "deceptive" information, the trustee writes in the review.

The prospectus is so full of deficiencies that the trustee assesses it is unlawful and in violation of the Danish Securities Act, the trustee writes. The insufficiencies are so significant that the prospectus does not abide to the law based on the information which the trustee had access to, but he writes "that there is most likely further relevant information which could have importance for an evaluation of the total prospectus."

Lacking cases

But the lack of a specified legal practice and the non-existence of previous similar cases mean, that the trustee is of the opinion that it should be up to a Danish court to decide if the prospectus is as insufficient as he has concluded.

The trustee assigns responsibility to a number of key figures in the dispute regarding the bankruptcy of OW Bunker.

This includes the CEO of OW Bunker, Jim Pedersen, the executives Jane Dahl Christensen and Götz Lehsten, as well as OW's CFO Morten Skou. Furthermore, Søren Johansen and Petter Samlin, partners in Altor, the equity fund backing OW Bunker, which according to the trustee have had intensive knowledge about the prospectus.

Board member Jakob Brogaard is under attack as well, as he has been on the board of OW companies since 2008.

He "should have reacted" and he should "not have acceded to" ... "the prospectus statement," as it is called.

Chairman exempt

On the other hand, the chairman of the board at OW Bunker, Niels Henrik Jensen, is shielded from liabilty. It cannot be clarified that he had such an extent of knowledge about the actual circumstances at OW Bunker that he can be held responsible. Add to this, the fact the he did not join the board until March of 2014, when the IPO was actually carried out, the trustee writes.

He also rejects targeting the former ØK executive Tom Behrens-Sørensen, as well as former DSV CEO Kurt Larsen for prospectus liability, writes the trustee.

Jim Pedersen's lawyer John Korsø Jensen declines to comment on the case. He has not seen the review, and he is not pleased with that.

"I have not read it and I do not wish to comment on it when they have been so incompetent as to release it, without presenting it to the parties involved," he says.

It was not possible to get a comment from Søren Johansen of Altor.

There are a number of areas, which are not properly mentioned in the prospectus, according to the trustee.

The series of holes

The review lists a number of issues: Incomplete financial reports leading up to the IPO, which are described as deceptive. Incomplete information on Dynamic Oil Trading in Singapore, which is not mentioned at all in the prospectus, but which ended up completely knocking OW Bunker to the ground, due to enormous amounts of credit given to one single customer.

In addition to this, it is not evident from the prospectus that the risk management in OW Bunker, was partly pure speculation. The investors just did not understand this, and at the investor meetings leading up to the IPO of OW Bunker, they asked for more information. Søren Halling-Overgaard covers these issues carefully and works as a so-called ad hoc trustee, as he single-handedly tries to find those responsible for compensation in the complex case.

He has had comprehensive access to information in the collapsed company and has discovered that investors, in the period before the share issue, have called for a lot more information regarding the full-blown speculation, which took place at OW Bunker regarding the rise and fall of the oil price.

Meanwhile, a sales process before the IPO showed that people with insight in bunker companies concluded, after reviewing OW Bunker, that the company was worth somewhere between 20 and 40 percent of the approximately USD 780 million which the company ended up generating in the IPO. The competent buyers, which ended up bidding low, simply subtract the budgeted growth of OW Bunker, as well as the extraordinary expenses for risk management, pure full-blown speculation, when they bid on the company, assesses the trustee.

Banks knew

The banks Morgan Stanley and Carnegie as well as the equity fund Altor Equity Partners, have been fully aware of these circumstances, the trustee writes.

He writes:

"The concerned parties have thus been aware, that the price formation, which took place in relation to the failed/canceled sales process and targeted towards industry savvy, potential buyers, could have a negative effect in the IPO" and continues - that there was an obvious need for knowledge about the risk management's significance for the earnings.

But the trustee concludes:

"... above mentioned conditions are not reflected in the final prospectus, which formed the foundation for the allocation..."

Major investors postpone OW lawsuit

Carrier forced to pay OW bunker-bill twice

OW trustee struggling to reach Asian customers

OW trustees question financial reports from 2011-2013 

Related articles:

  • Photo: Kasper Palsnov/Jyllands-Posten

    Major investors postpone OW lawsuit

    For subscribers

  • Photo: Kasper Palsnov/Jyllands-Posten

    OW trustees question financial reports from 2011-2013

    For subscribers

  • Photo: OW Bunker

    Carrier forced to pay OW bunker-bill twice

    For subscribers

Sign up for our newsletter

Stay ahead of development by receiving our newsletter on the latest sector knowledge.

!
Newsletter terms

Front page now

Photo: Höegh Autoliners
Carriers

Car carriers have rarely seen such profits: "We are probably at an all-time high"

After a difficult time during the pandemic, 2022 has exceeded all expectations for car carriers, says chief exec of Höegh Autoliners. Low capacity and electric cars out of China are main factors in elevating prices.
  • Norwegian carrier lands another large gas deal with Germany
  • Höegh Autoliners joins climate coalition

For subscribers

Photo: Markus Scholz/AP/Ritzau Scanpix
Container

Maersk rebrands Hamburg Süd and several other well-known subsidiaries

For subscribers

Photo: Ints Kalnins/Reuters/Ritzau Scanpix/REUTERS / X02120
Tanker

Fredriksen now owns nearly as many Euronav shares as the Saverys family

For subscribers

”Blue Water wants to grow – but it will be with a focus on profitable growth, and we will hold on to our strong values, unique customer focus and high level of satisfaction among both customers and personnel,” states Kurt Skov, founder and departing chair at Blue Water Shipping. | Foto: Carsten Andreasen/Ritzau Scanpix
Logistics

Blue Water founder promises future "focus on profitable growth"

For subscribers

Foto: Tatiana Meel/Reuters/Ritzau Scanpix
Regulation

EU considers capping Russian fuel prices at USD 100 a barrel

For subscribers

Foto: Statoil/AP/Ritzau Scanpix
Offshore

Borr Drilling raises USD 400m to pay off debt

For subscribers

Further reading

Photo: Höegh Autoliners
Carriers

Car carriers have rarely seen such profits: "We are probably at an all-time high"

After a difficult time during the pandemic, 2022 has exceeded all expectations for car carriers, says chief exec of Höegh Autoliners. Low capacity and electric cars out of China are main factors in elevating prices.

For subscribers

Chief execs of Maersk and MSC, Vincent Clerc and Søren Toft, acknowledges that much have changed for the carriers since launching the 2M alliance. For that reason, the partnership is now ended. | Foto: Jacob Gronholt-pedersen/reuters/ritzau Scanpix og Jason Decrow/ap/ritzau Scanpix
Container

End of 2M alliance could trigger a domino effect

A new reality on freight markets and a need for fewer ties could be main reasons behind MSC and Maersk terminating their partnership. More alliance dissolutions could be coming, according to shipping analyst.

For subscribers

Photo: Markus Scholz/AP/Ritzau Scanpix
Container

Maersk rebrands Hamburg Süd and several other well-known subsidiaries

Hamburg Süd will lose its company name and gradually be integrated into the Maersk brand. A number of other subsidiaries face rebranding as well.

For subscribers

Latest news

  • Blue Water founder promises future "focus on profitable growth" – 27 Jan
  • Borr Drilling raises USD 400m to pay off debt – 27 Jan
  • Income for ice class tankers has surged by 1,644 percent following sanctions – 27 Jan
  • Floating power station to provide energy for one million Ukrainians – 27 Jan
  • Maersk rebrands Hamburg Süd and several other well-known subsidiaries – 27 Jan
  • Car carriers have rarely seen such profits: "We are probably at an all-time high" – 27 Jan
  • Fredriksen now owns nearly as many Euronav shares as the Saverys family – 27 Jan
  • EU considers capping Russian fuel prices at USD 100 a barrel – 27 Jan
  • New partnership to investigate potential human rights abuse at sea – 27 Jan
  • Singaporean competition authorities to probe DSME sale – 27 Jan
See all

Jobs

  • Junior Finance Business Partner - offshore wind industry

  • Chartering Manager for Lauritzen Bulkers A/S

  • Financial Controller for International Shipping Company

  • Foundation Package Manager - Offshore wind industry

  • Senior Lead, Human Sustainability at Sea

  • Copenhagen Shipping Company is hiring a skilled cargo broker

Jobs

  • Junior Finance Business Partner - offshore wind industry

  • Chartering Manager for Lauritzen Bulkers A/S

  • Financial Controller for International Shipping Company

  • Foundation Package Manager - Offshore wind industry

  • Senior Lead, Human Sustainability at Sea

  • Copenhagen Shipping Company is hiring a skilled cargo broker

See all jobs

Colophon

ShippingWatch
Search

Sections

  • Carriers
  • Logistics
  • Regulation
  • Suppliers
  • Offshore
  • Ports
  • Sitemap
  • RSS feeds

Editor

Tomas Kristiansen

tk@shippingwatch.dk

Tel.: +45 3330 8360

Editor-in-chief

Anders Heering

Publisher

JP/Politiken Media Group Ltd

Advertising

annoncering@infowatch.dk

Tel.: +45 7077 7445

Advertising

Job Advertising

job@infowatch.dk

Tel.: +45 7077 7445

Jobs

Subscription

Try ShippingWatch or get an offer for a subscription meeting the exact needs of you or your company.

shippingwatch@infowatch.dk

Tel.: +45 7077 7445

Learn more about subscriptions here

Address

ShippingWatch

Rådhuspladsen 37

1785 Copenhagen K, Denmark

Tel.: +45 3330 8360

Guidelines

  • Privacy Policy

Copyright © ShippingWatch — All rights reserved

Microsoft is in the process of discontinuing Internet Explorer – and so are we.
For a better experience, we recommend using one of the following browsers.

Kind regards,
ShippingWatch

Google ChromeMozilla FirefoxMicrosoft Edge