A part of Watch Media

ShippingWatchMonday6 February 2023

  • Search
  • Log in
  • Carriers
  • Logistics
  • Regulation
  • Suppliers
  • Search
  • Log in
  • Latest
  • Search
  • Log in
  • Carriers
  • Logistics
  • Regulation
  • Suppliers
  • Offshore
  • Ports
17/06/2014at 12:17

China rejects P3 alliance

The Chinese competition authorities have rejected the P3 alliance. The collaboration has been abandoned in its current form, says Maersk in a corporate statement. The Chinese saw the alliance agreement as a merger.
Photo: Maersk Line
BY KATRINE GRØNVALD RAUN

The Chinese Ministry of Commerce (MOFCOM) announced on Tuesday that it has decided not to approve the planned large-scale alliance between the three largest carriers in the world, Maersk Line, CMA CGM, and MSC, says Maersk in a corporate statement.

According to Maersk, the decision follows a review under China's merger control rules.

"The Partners take note of and respect MOFCOM’s decision. Subsequently, the Partners have agreed to stop the preparatory work on the P3 Network and the P3 Network as initially planned will not come into existence. The lack of implementation of the P3 Network will have no material impact on the Maersk Group’s expected result for 2014," says Maersk.

The announcement likely comes as a huge surprise to many industry players and observers, as the network agreement has been cleared by US Federal Maritime Commission, FMC, and as recently as early June the EU Commission announced that it had no objections to the 3 alliance, though the Commission would keep a close watch on the collaboration to ensure compliance with competition rules.

Several analysts have recently predicted that the major alliance would result in an overhaul of the entire container market and create a player that would be able to dominate the other carriers.

China saw P3 alliance as a merger

The world's biggest and most comprehensive container alliance ever, the P3 alliance, was ruled out because the Chinese saw the agreement as constituting a de facto merger between the three European carriers, Maersk Line, CMA CGM, and MSC, says Maersk Line Trade and Marketing Officer Vincent Clerc, who for the past two and a half years has served as the Danish carrier's chief negotiator along with the two European shipowning families, Aponte from Swiss MSC and Saade of French CMA CGM.

"According to Chinese jurisdiction P3 was considered a merger. This differs from the opinion of authorities that have so far dealt with the alliance. But there's nothing we can do about that. This is the decision of a sovereign state, and that's why P3 will not be realized," says Vincent Clerc.

Smedegaard: Chinese decision is a surprise

The Chinese authorities' decision to reject the massive collaboration between Maersk Line, CMA CGM and MSC comes as a surprise to Group CEO Nils Smedegaard:

"The decision does come as a surprise to us, of course, as the partners have worked hard to address all the regulators’ concerns. The P3 alliance would have enabled Maersk Line to make further reductions in cost and CO2 emissions and not least improve its services to its customers with a more efficient vessel network," he says in a statement:

"Nevertheless, I’m quite confident Maersk Line will accomplish those improvements anyway. It has delivered on those improvements over the last five quarters in the absence of P3 and I’m confident it will continue to do so."

Do you want to stay up to date on the latest developments in International shipping? Subscribe to our newsletter – the first 40 days are free

Maersk Line's Trade and Marketing Officer Vincent Clerc is also surprised, and he says in the statement that the carrier has been working hard with the Chinese authorities.

"So of course it is a disappointment. P3 would have provided Maersk Line with a more efficient network and our customers with a better product," he says.

Maersk Line stresses in the statement that the carrier has been working with China for more than 80 years and that the company will continue to work with the Chinese authorities.

Has done very well

In a comment Fearnleys Securities says about the decision:

"Maersk Line has done exceptionally well in recent years in cutting costs and improving margins, and has consistently out-performed peers. The company does not expect the lack of implementation to have any “material impact on the Maersk Group's expected result for 2014”. We believe that today’s announcement is negative for the company’s share price development in the short term, but make no revisions to our earnings estimates for the year."

The P3 alliance binds the partners for ten years

Wall Street Journal: China to approve P3 in June

EU clears the P3 alliance

SeaIntel: P3 will dominate on fuel 

Related articles:

  • The P3 alliance binds the partners for ten years

    For subscribers

  • Photo: Maersk Line

    Wall Street Journal: China to approve P3 in June

    For subscribers

  • EU clears the P3 alliance

    For subscribers

Sign up for our newsletter

Stay ahead of development by receiving our newsletter on the latest sector knowledge.

!
Newsletter terms

Front page now

Palle Laursen has spent almost his entire career at Maersk where he began as a maritime engineer in 1998. He now retires as chief of fleet. | Foto: Maersk
Container

Maersk's chief of fleet leaves after 25 years as reshuffling continues

Palle Laursen leaves Maersk after 25 years in the company. Another leader is also out the door, as Vincent Clerc continues to put his stamp on the shipping giant.
  • Vincent Clerc sets brand new executive team
  • New executive team to steer Maersk through recession: "A lot of highly experienced industry people"

For subscribers

Lars Jensen is a shipping analyst and founder of consultancy Vespucci Maritime. In the future, he will write two opinion pieces for ShippingWatch a month. | Foto: Magnus Møller
Container

Opinion: Maersk and MSC heading for direct confrontation over customers

For subscribers

Foto: Uncredited/AP/Ritzau Scanpix
Tanker

New Russia sanctions could eventually leave Europe in drastic need of diesel

For subscribers

"Vi har nogle gange haft ry for at have et kortere aftræk end vores konkurrenter. Du kan godt regne med, at det ry vil vi gerne holde fast i," siger Jens Lund, driftsdirektør i DSV. | Foto: DSV
Logistics

DSV denies savings plan but is attentive to costs

For subscribers

Foto: PR / Euronav
Tanker

Euronav CEO defends decision to retain large dividend

For subscribers

Foto: Mike Blake/REUTERS / X00030
Container

Freight rates out of China continue to plummet

Further reading

Foto: Uncredited/AP/Ritzau Scanpix
Tanker

New Russia sanctions could eventually leave Europe in drastic need of diesel

It will be difficult to replace the existing supply of Russian oil products when new EU sanctions come into force on Sunday, according to one broker. Hafnia predicts a strong market.

For subscribers

Palle Laursen has spent almost his entire career at Maersk where he began as a maritime engineer in 1998. He now retires as chief of fleet. | Foto: Maersk
Container

Maersk's chief of fleet leaves after 25 years as reshuffling continues

Palle Laursen leaves Maersk after 25 years in the company. Another leader is also out the door, as Vincent Clerc continues to put his stamp on the shipping giant.

For subscribers

Foto: Staff/Reuters/Ritzau Scanpix
Logistics

DSV sees one advantage of downturn: It will be cheaper to buy competitors

Acquisitions are decisive for growth at logistics group DSV, and with prospects of declining freight volumes, the prices of acquisitions will fall. DSV will use this to its advantage, according to CEO Jens Bjørn Andersen.

For subscribers

Latest news

  • Freight rates out of China continue to plummet – 3 Feb
  • Ziton wins multi-year deal with German utility – 3 Feb
  • Euronav CEO defends decision to retain large dividend – 3 Feb
  • DSV denies savings plan but is attentive to costs – 3 Feb
  • DP World to construct large port terminal in India – 3 Feb
  • Maersk's chief of fleet leaves after 25 years as reshuffling continues – 3 Feb
  • Clarksons banks on offshore wind with new US office – 3 Feb
  • Opinion: Maersk and MSC heading for direct confrontation over customers – 3 Feb
  • Bulgaria to keep up export flows of Russian fuels to Ukraine – 3 Feb
  • New Russia sanctions could eventually leave Europe in drastic need of diesel – 3 Feb
See all

Jobs

  • Ambitious employee for Shipping office wanted

  • Copenhagen Shipping Company is hiring a skilled cargo broker

  • Chartering Manager for Lauritzen Bulkers A/S

  • Foundation Package Manager - Offshore wind industry

  • Senior Lead, Human Sustainability at Sea

  • Fleet Manager

  • Senior Financial Controller

Jobs

  • Ambitious employee for Shipping office wanted

  • Copenhagen Shipping Company is hiring a skilled cargo broker

  • Chartering Manager for Lauritzen Bulkers A/S

  • Foundation Package Manager - Offshore wind industry

  • Senior Lead, Human Sustainability at Sea

  • Fleet Manager

  • Senior Financial Controller

See all jobs

Colophon

ShippingWatch
Search

Sections

  • Carriers
  • Logistics
  • Regulation
  • Suppliers
  • Offshore
  • Ports
  • Sitemap
  • RSS feeds

Editor

Tomas Kristiansen

tk@shippingwatch.dk

Tel.: +45 3330 8360

Editor-in-chief

Anders Heering

Publisher

JP/Politiken Media Group Ltd

Advertising

annoncering@infowatch.dk

Tel.: +45 7077 7445

Advertising

Job Advertising

job@infowatch.dk

Tel.: +45 7077 7445

Jobs

Subscription

Try ShippingWatch or get an offer for a subscription meeting the exact needs of you or your company.

shippingwatch@infowatch.dk

Tel.: +45 7077 7445

Learn more about subscriptions here

Address

ShippingWatch

Rådhuspladsen 37

1785 Copenhagen K, Denmark

Tel.: +45 3330 8360

Guidelines

  • Privacy Policy

Copyright © ShippingWatch — All rights reserved

Microsoft is in the process of discontinuing Internet Explorer – and so are we.
For a better experience, we recommend using one of the following browsers.

Kind regards,
ShippingWatch

Google ChromeMozilla FirefoxMicrosoft Edge