A part of Watch Media

ShippingWatchTuesday7 February 2023

  • Search
  • Log in
  • Carriers
  • Logistics
  • Regulation
  • Suppliers
  • Search
  • Log in
  • Latest
  • Search
  • Log in
  • Carriers
  • Logistics
  • Regulation
  • Suppliers
  • Offshore
  • Ports
11/10/2013at 09:24

Why the EU will scrutinize new Maersk alliance

Several conditions indicate that the European Commission will subject the planned mega alliance between Maersk Line, MSC, and CMA CGM to close scrutiny, even though the EU will not have to formally approve the large-scale collaboration, a legal expert tells ShippingWatch.
BY OLE ANDERSEN

Even though the EU Commission will not formally have to approve the P3 alliance between the world’s three biggest carriers, Maersk Line, Mediterranean Shipping Co (MSC), and CMA CGM, there are several reasons why officials in Brussels might want to closely scrutinize the details of the collaboration and its consequences, says Filippo Lorenzon, Director of Institute of Maritime Law at University of Southampton and Consultant at Campbell Johnston Clark Ltd in London, in an interview with ShippingWatch.

Do you want to stay up to date on the latest developments in Danish and International shipping? Subscribe to our newsletter – first 40 days are free

The planned launch of the collaboration, which is unprecedented in terms of the alliance’s scope, coincides with a public consultation by the EU in 2014 concerning the application of the EU competition law and the shipping industry.

“In May 2011 the Commission launched an investigation into the container liner shipping sector and a review of the liner consortia block exemption is currently due in 2015, with a full public consultation scheduled for 2014. In light of this it would not be surprising if the Commission takes a particularly close look at the finer details of the Alliance,” says Filippo Lorenzon.

P3 has more than 27 percent share of US container market 

The EU barred the liner carrier conferences, the so-called Consortia Block Exemption Regulation, in 2008, but this regulation still exempts “agreement[s] between two or more vessel-operating carriers which provide international liner shipping services exclusively for the carriage of cargo, chiefly by container.” This would include consortiums such as the P3 alliance.

“But in order for the P3 carriers to qualify for such an exemption their market share cannot exceed 30 percent in each market in which the alliance operates,” says Filippo Lorenzon.

“Maersk, Mediterranean Shipping Co. and CMA CGM together currently have about 37% of the world’s total container capacity although this does not necessarily mean that the P3 Alliance will exceed the 30% limit in each of the relevant market sectors.  In case it will, the Alliance will not be allowed to rely on the block exemption and the agreement will fall to be assessed under the EU’s ordinary laws regarding this kind of agreement (Article 101 of the Treaty),” says Filippo Lorenzon.

Since the planned P3 alliance was announced, a series of shipping analysts have studied the carriers’ total strength on several trade routes. On the key route between Asia and Northern Europe the Alliance, according to Drewry, will control 46 percent of the capacity, and on the string between Asia and the Middle East, the three carriers will have 55 percent of the market. P3’s market share on the Atlantic routes and the Pacific will be 35 percent and 29 percent, respectively, says Drewry.

Lack of P3 plan brings overcapacity to the market 

Analysts SeaIntel concluded in August 2013 in a survey of the future competitive conditions on the routes between Asia and Europe that P3, with a total of 255 ships, 2.6 million teu, would not only have a significantly bigger market share than all of its competitors, the Alliance would also benefit from economies of scale that no one will be able to match.

Benefits of the P3 collaboration

According to Filippo Lorenzon, the P3 alliance is fairly well placed for the EU Commission to evaluate the collaboration in light of the Treaty’s Article 101, the first step of which is to verify whether the collaboration and the agreement between the three carriers has an anticompetitive object or actual or potential anti-competitive effects. The second step, which only becomes relevant when an agreement is found to be restrictive of competition under Article 101(1), is to determine under Article 101(3) any benefits produced by the agreement and assess whether these positive effects outweigh its anti-competitive effects. This assessment is one of fact rather than law, says Filippo Lorenzon.

P3 will bring crucial savings 

In other words, the agreement must contribute to improving the production or distribution of goods or to promoting technical or economic progress.

“Given the current economic situation of the liner shipping sector, with rock bottom market rates and enormous over capacity the P3 Alliance could go some way to improving the situation and providing much needed stability.  This would certainly qualify as contributing to economic progress in an area in desperate need of a boost.”

Filippo Lorenzon points out that a key factor related to the EU’s approval of the P3 collaboration is that the desired improvement as regards the perpetual overcapacity issue, market stability and general efficacy could likely not be achieved as effectively without the creation of the alliance, and that it can be argued that any potential restriction on competition flowing from the agreement is reasonably necessary for the attainment of the desired efficiencies.

“This is also perhaps assisted by the fact that this agreement appears to be purely operational in nature with a new, arm’s-length, operating company to be set up to manage the ships in the network, with all sales and customer allocation remaining in full control of the respective companies,” says Filippo Lorenzon.

Do you want to stay up to date on the latest developments in Danish and International shipping? Subscribe to our newsletter – first 40 days are free

KG funds are the only ones certain to lose on Triple-E 

Shippers worry about new mega ships and alliances 

P3 CEO: These are the challenges for the alliance 

Related articles:

  • Photo: Carsten Bundgaard

    KG funds are the only ones certain to lose on Triple-E

  • Photo: APM Terminals

    Shippers worry about new mega ships and alliances

    For subscribers

  • P3 CEO: These are the challenges for the alliance

Sign up for our newsletter

Stay ahead of development by receiving our newsletter on the latest sector knowledge.

!
Newsletter terms

Front page now

Maersk CEO Vincent Clerc (left) and MSC CEO Søren Toft are following very different strategic directions. | Foto: Jacob Gronholt-pedersen/reuters/ritzau Scanpix og Jason Decrow/ap/ritzau Scanpix
Container

Maersk could be heading for a price war with MSC

After a profit of historic proportions in 2022, Maersk is facing a new reality this year, entailing a potential price war unleashed by the carrier’s partner in the disbanded 2M alliance, MSC, predicts Drewry.
  • Opinion: Maersk and MSC heading for direct confrontation over customers
  • Drewry director eyes one central weakness in Maersk's strategy

For subscribers

Krisen på fragtmarkedet styrker DSV's position i forhold til rederierne: ”I og med at vi er en af de store aftagere af søfragt, har vi også et samarbejde med rederierne, som er strategisk og forankret i direktionen,” siger DSV's topchef, Jens Bjørn Andersen. | Foto: Lars Krabbe/Foto: Lars Krabbe/Ritzau Scanpix
Logistics

DSV to support box carriers that provided help during Covid chaos

For subscribers

Foto: Rebecca Naden
Tanker

Countdown to clash over Euronav's board composition has begun

For subscribers

Maersk is heading for its second record profit, setting a new benchmark in Danish business history. | Foto: Jonas Walzberg/AP/Ritzau Scanpix
Container

Maersk on track to achieve record profit for second consecutive year

For subscribers

Foto: Sund & Bælt
Offshore

Danish authorities suspending 23GW of offshore wind projects

For subscribers

Foto: Casper Dalhoff / Ritzau Scanpix
Container

Maersk redirects traffic following earthquake

For subscribers

Further reading

Foto: Magnus Møller
Featured

Eitzen son wants to electrify shipping as new CEO of Christiania Shipping

New Christiania Shipping CEO Fridtjof C. Eitzen maintains that acquisitions are on hold after a record year. The 36-year-old marine engineer, fifth generation in the Eitzen dynasty, wants to electrify shipping.

For subscribers

Maersk is heading for its second record profit, setting a new benchmark in Danish business history. | Foto: Jonas Walzberg/AP/Ritzau Scanpix
Container

Maersk on track to achieve record profit for second consecutive year

Wednesday, Maersk will probably announce a financial result for the Danish business history annals. Shareholders face dividends of USD 11.2bn, one analyst estimates.

For subscribers

Maersk CEO Vincent Clerc (left) and MSC CEO Søren Toft are following very different strategic directions. | Foto: Jacob Gronholt-pedersen/reuters/ritzau Scanpix og Jason Decrow/ap/ritzau Scanpix
Container

Maersk could be heading for a price war with MSC

After a profit of historic proportions in 2022, Maersk is facing a new reality this year, entailing a potential price war unleashed by the carrier’s partner in the disbanded 2M alliance, MSC, predicts Drewry.

For subscribers

Jobs

  • Fleet Manager

  • Foundation Package Manager - Offshore wind industry

  • Senior Financial Controller

  • Vessel Manager Marine and QA

  • Head of P2X Marketing and Sales (m/f/d)

  • Copenhagen Shipping Company is hiring a skilled cargo broker

  • Commercial Contract Manager for the Offshore Wind Industry

  • Chartering Manager for Lauritzen Bulkers A/S

  • Ambitious employee for Shipping office wanted

See all jobs

Latest news

  • DSV to support box carriers that provided help during Covid chaos – 15:56
  • More tankers embark on illicit sailings following embargo on Russian oil – 15:33
  • Monjasa to provide green ammonia through new collaboration – 15:27
  • Countdown to clash over Euronav's board composition has begun – 15:17
  • New major port project underway in the Baltic Sea region – 15:05
  • Bank DNB sees box market reach record lows in coming years – 14:24
  • Maersk on track to achieve record profit for second consecutive year – 13:32
  • Maersk could be heading for a price war with MSC – 12:53
  • Oil prices extend gains following earthquake and Chinese demand rebound – 10:25
  • Maersk redirects traffic following earthquake – 08:52
See all

Jobs

  • Fleet Manager

  • Foundation Package Manager - Offshore wind industry

  • Senior Financial Controller

  • Vessel Manager Marine and QA

  • Head of P2X Marketing and Sales (m/f/d)

  • Copenhagen Shipping Company is hiring a skilled cargo broker

  • Commercial Contract Manager for the Offshore Wind Industry

  • Chartering Manager for Lauritzen Bulkers A/S

  • Ambitious employee for Shipping office wanted

See all jobs

Colophon

ShippingWatch
Search

Sections

  • Carriers
  • Logistics
  • Regulation
  • Suppliers
  • Offshore
  • Ports
  • Sitemap
  • RSS feeds

Editor

Tomas Kristiansen

tk@shippingwatch.dk

Tel.: +45 3330 8360

  • About ShippingWatch

Editor-in-chief

Anders Heering

Publisher

JP/Politiken Media Group Ltd

Advertising

annoncering@infowatch.dk

Tel.: +45 7077 7445

Advertising

Job Advertising

job@infowatch.dk

Tel.: +45 7077 7445

Jobs

Subscription

Try ShippingWatch or get an offer for a subscription meeting the exact needs of you or your company.

shippingwatch@infowatch.dk

Tel.: +45 7077 7445

Learn more about subscriptions here

Address

ShippingWatch

Rådhuspladsen 37

1785 Copenhagen K, Denmark

Tel.: +45 3330 8360

Guidelines

  • Privacy Policy

Copyright © ShippingWatch — All rights reserved

Microsoft is in the process of discontinuing Internet Explorer – and so are we.
For a better experience, we recommend using one of the following browsers.

Kind regards,
ShippingWatch

Google ChromeMozilla FirefoxMicrosoft Edge